The following should be carefully reviewed prior to submission.
Guidelines for Clinical Trials:
In accordance with the Clinical Trial Registration Statement from the International Committee of Medical Journal Editors (Circulation. 2005;111:1337 and http://content.nejm.org/cgi/content/full/NEJMe078110 ), all clinical trials in Circulation: Cardiovascular Interventions must be registered in a public trials registry at or before the onset of participant enrollment. This requirement applies to all clinical trials that begin enrollment after July 1, 2005 and applies to all clinical trials, including Phase 1 studies. Any research study that prospectively assigns human participants or groups of humans to one or more health-related intervention(s) to evaluate the effects on health outcomes is considered a clinical trial. The special report, The Proposed Rule for U.S. Clinical Trial Registration and Results Submission published in The New England Journal of Medicine, can be consulted for the guidance.
Those who are uncertain whether their trial meets the ICMJE definition of a clinical trial should err on the side of registration if they wish to seek publication.
The registry must be accessible to the public at no charge, searchable, open to all prospective registrants, and managed by a not-for-profit organization. The registry must include the following information: a unique identifying number, a statement of the intervention(s), study hypothesis, definition of primary and secondary outcome measurements, eligibility criteria, target number of subjects, funding source, contact information for the principal investigator, and key dates (registration date, start date, and completion date).
The registry sponsored by the United States National Library of Medicine (http://www.clinicaltrials.gov ) meets these requirements and is recommended by the editors.
Other registries are acceptable if they meet these requirements. In addition to http://www.clinicaltrials.gov, the following registries are recommended by the ICMJE:
In accordance with the ICMJE’s recommendation, we will also accept registration of clinical trials in any of the primary registers that participate in the World Health Organization’s International Clinical Trial Registry Platform. Primary registers are WHO-selected registers managed by not-for-profit entities that will accept registrations for any interventional trials, delete duplicate entries from their own register, and provide data directly to the WHO. Please note that registration in any WHO partner registers is insufficient.
The authors will be requested to provide the exact URL and unique identification number for the trial registration at the time of submission. Since this information will be published, we ask that you include a fourth heading in your abstract: "Clinical Trial Registration Information". Please list the URL, as well as the unique identifier, for the publicly accessible web site on which the trial is registered in this section.
Clinical trial reports should also comply with the Consolidated Standards of Reporting Trials (CONSORT) and include a flow diagram presenting the enrollment, intervention allocation, follow-up, and data analysis with number of subjects for each (http://www.consort-statement.org/?o=1011). Please also refer specifically to the CONSORT Checklist of items to include when reporting a randomized clinical trial.
Results posted in the same clinical trials registry in which the primary registration resides will not be considered prior publication if they are presented in the form of a brief abstract (≤500 words) or a table.
Transparency and Openness Promotion (TOP) Guidelines for Authors Publishing in an American Heart Association Journal:
The policy of American Heart Association journals* is to publish papers where data, program code and other methods are appropriately cited using DOIs, journal citations, or other persistent identifiers. Such materials should be recognized as original intellectual contributions and afforded recognition through citation.
Data set citation format:
Creator (PublicationYear). Title. Publisher. Identifier
Data set citation example:
Chen, J. et al. Common genetic variation in ETV6 is associated with colorectal cancer susceptibility. Dryad Digital Repository. doi:10.5061/dryad.7dj7t (2016).
Data, Analytic Methods (Code), and Research Materials Transparency
The policy of American Heart Association journals* is to publish papers where authors indicate whether the data, methods used in the analysis, and materials used to conduct the research will be made available to any researcher for purposes of reproducing the results or replicating the procedure.
1. Authors must, at the beginning of the Methods section, indicate if they will or will not make their data, analytic methods, and study materials available to other researchers.
2. If an author agrees to make materials available, the author must specify where that material will be available and is responsible for maintaining availability.
Design and Analysis Transparency
The policy of the American Heart Association journals* is to publish papers where authors follow standards for disclosing key aspects of the research design and data analysis. Authors are encouraged to review the standards available for many research applications from http://www.equator-network.org/ and use those that are relevant for the reported research applications.
Preregistration of Studies and Analysis Plans
The policy of the American Heart Association journals* is to publish papers that include a link to pre-registration of the study and/or analysis plan if applicable. Preregistration of studies involves registering the study design, variables, and treatment conditions (e.g., http://clinicaltrials.gov/, http://socialscienceregistry.org/, http://openscienceframework.org/, http://egap.org/design-registration/, http://ridie.3ieimpact.org/). Including an analysis plan involves specification of sequence of analyses or the statistical model that will be reported.
1. If authors have preregistered the study, a link to the pre-registration or the registry and unique identifier of the pre-registration must be included at the beginning of the Methods section upon submission of the paper.
2. If an author preregistered the research with an analysis plan, the author must:
a. confirm in the text that the study was registered prior to conducting the research with links to the time-stamped preregistration(s) at the institutional registry, and that the preregistration adheres to the disclosure requirements of the institutional registry or those required for the preregistered badge with analysis plans maintained by the Center for Open Science.
b. report all preregistered analyses in the text, or, if there were changes in the analysis plan following preregistration, those changes must be disclosed with explanation for the changes.
c. clearly distinguish in text analyses that were preregistered from those that were not, such as having separate sections in the results for confirmatory and exploratory analyses.
The policy of the American Heart Association journals* is to hold replication studies to the same standards as other content submitted to the journals.
*Including Arteriosclerosis, Thrombosis, and Vascular Biology (ATVB), Circulation, Circulation: Arrhythmia and Electrophysiology, Circulation: Cardiovascular Genetics, Circulation: Cardiovascular Imaging, Circulation: Cardiovascular Interventions, Circulation: Cardiovascular Quality and Outcomes, Circulation: Heart Failure, Circulation Research, Hypertension, Journal of the American Heart Association (JAHA), Stroke
Guidelines for Meta-Analyses:
See “Meta-analysis of Observational Studies in Epidemiology: A Proposal for Reporting,” JAMA. 2000;283:2008-2012.
Guidelines for Studies on Diagnostic Tests:
See “The STARD Statement for Reporting Studies of Diagnostic Accuracy: Explanation and Elaboration,” Ann Intern Med. 2003;138:40-44.
Guidelines for Human Phenotype–Genotype Association or Linkage Studies:
- Reporting issues:
- Report process for selecting genes and SNPs.
- Report Hardy-Weinberg statistics or p-values and method of calculating same.
- Refer to existing public domain websites for the Human Gene Ontology name and the rs number for SNPs.
- Describe genotyping methods. If numerous primers have been used, please include them in an online supplement.
- False positive and false negative concerns. Given well-described problems with both false positive and false negative associations, phenotype-genotype association studies should meet some or all of the criteria below:
- Phenotype is clearly defined, is heritable, and if a quantitative phenotype is reported, reproducibility data are provided.
- The sample size is adequate to detect a SNP or haplotype with a modest effect. For genotype-trait associations, provide an estimate of the effect size that could be detected with power 0.80 or higher with the allele frequency and sample size reported.
- Since multiple statistical testing methods are frequently used in genotyping-phenotyping studies, please include specifics of the primary model(s) tested. Nonessential secondary models may be published as electronic data supplements. Clinically relevant confounders should be included in multivariable models or residuals.
- Review criteria for human linkage studies. Manuscripts should include the following:
- Identifying plausible candidate genes under the linkage peak.
- Follow-up fine mapping to narrow the region of linkage, and/or genotyping some of the candidate genes under the linkage peak.
- Replication data from another sample.
Guidelines for Genomic and Proteomic Studies:
- Preparation of Data Submitted: Data should follow the MIAME checklist (for more information see http://www.mged.org/Workgroups/MIAME/miame_checklist.html ).
- Accessibility of Data: Authors of papers that include genomic, proteomic, or other high-throughput data are required to make their data easily accessible for the reviewers and the editors during the review process.
- You may submit your data to the NCBI gene expression and hybridization array data repository (GEO, http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/geo/) and provide the GEO accession number; or
- You may provide a link to a secure or publicly accessible website which hosts the data. Prior to publication, the data must be submitted and an accession number obtained. Access to the information in the database must be available at the time of publication. GEO has a web-based submission route, suitable for a small number of samples, or a batch submission tool (called SOFT). GEO is accessible from http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/geo/. The submission FAQ is available at http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/projects/geo/info/faq.html.
Guidelines for Proteins and Nucleic Acid Sequences:
Newly reported nucleotide or protein sequences must be deposited in GenBank or EMBL databases, and an accession number must be obtained. Access to the information in the database must be available at the time of publication. Authors are responsible for arranging release of data at the time of publication. The authors must also provide a statement in the manuscript that this sequence has been scanned against the database and all sequences with significant relatedness to the new sequence identified (and their accession numbers included in the text of the manuscript).
National Center for Biotechnology Information
8600 Rockville Pike, Building 38A
Bethesda, MD 20894
Tel: (301) 496-2475
On the web at: http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/Genbank/index.html
- EMBL Nucleotide Sequence Submissions
European Bioinformatics Institute
Hinxton, Cambridge CB10 1SD, UK
Tel.: 44-1223-494401; Fax: 44-1223-494472
On the web at: http://www.ebi.ac.uk
- DNA Data Bank of Japan
Center for Information Biology
National Institute of Genetics
Mishima, Shizuoka, 411, Japan
Tel.: 81-559-81-6853; Fax: 81-559-81-6849
On the web at: http://www.ddbj.nig.ac.jp
Submission to any data bank is sufficient to ensure entry in all.